Droit Immobilier

Subject to cassation is the judgment which, in order to

📅 Décision du 28 June 1995⚖️ Cour de cassation👁️ 3 vues📖 2 min de lecture

A judgment is subject to cassation which, in order to dismiss a co-owner's application for annulment of decisions of a general meeting, holds that the sending of the documents referred to in Article 11-3° of the Decree of 17 March 1967 was not necessary even though the agenda included approval of the withdrawal from the original co-ownership of one of its constituent buildings and approval of the new co-ownership regulations and service charge apportionment statements, no amendment to the former instruments being contemplated and only adaptation of the former instruments to the new situation being envisaged, whereas it followed from its own findings that no corresponding draft resolution had been notified to the co-owners prior to the agenda or simultaneously therewith.

Reference decision: cc • N° 93-18.091 • 1995-06-28 • View decision →

This decision sheds important light on your property law. Here is what it changes for you.

The situation

A judgment is subject to cassation which, in order to dismiss a co-owner's application for annulment of decisions of a general meeting, holds that the sending of the documents referred to in Article 11-3° of the Decree of 17 March 1967 was not necessary even though the agenda included approval of the withdrawal from the original co-ownership of one of its constituent buildings and approval of the new co-ownership regulations and service charge apportionment statements, no amendment to the former instruments being contemplated and only adaptation of the former instruments to the new situation being envisaged, whereas it followed from its own findings that no corresponding draft resolution had been notified to the co-owners prior to the agenda or simultaneously therewith.

What the law says

This decision confirms the fundamental principles of property law.

Key points

  • Strictly respect statutory time limits for appeals
  • Keep all your supporting documents (title deeds, instruments, correspondence)
  • Anticipate: preventive advice always costs less than litigation

For an analysis of your situation: 30 min consultation at €45 with Maître Zakine.

📌 Does this apply to your situation? Maître Cécile Zakine, French real estate lawyer, practises throughout France.
→ Prendre RDV pour une consultation droit du travail  |  → Browse all our legal articles

Informations juridiques

  • Numéro: 93-18.091
  • Juridiction: Cour de cassation
  • Date de décision: 28 juin 1995

Mots-clés

droit immobilierjurisprudenceimmobilier

Cas d'usage pratiques

1

Challenging a General Meeting Decision on Converting a Commercial Unit

Sophie, a co-owner in a 50-flat building in Nice, discovers that the recent AGM voted to convert a residential flat into a commercial office without sending her the draft resolution beforehand. She received only the agenda, and the decision results in higher service charges for her lot.

Application pratique:

The Court of Cassation (28 June 1995) ruled that for significant changes like modifying co-ownership regulations or charge allocations, the managing agent must notify co-owners of the draft resolutions before or with the agenda. Sophie can challenge the decision by filing an annulment action within two months of receiving the minutes, citing this case law. She should gather evidence (agenda, minutes, and any correspondence) and contact a solicitor promptly to assess her chances.

2

Avoiding Procedural Flaws When Detaching a Building from the Co-ownership

As a managing agent in Lyon, you plan to propose at the next AGM the withdrawal of one building from the co-ownership and approval of new service charge apportionments. You initially assume no draft resolution is needed because you view it as an adaptation, not a formal amendment.

Application pratique:

The 1995 ruling emphasises that even if a change is presented as an 'adaptation', the co-owners must receive the full draft resolutions (including withdrawal terms, new regulations, and updated charge statements) no later than with the agenda—typically at least 21 days before the meeting. You must send these documents by recorded delivery to every co-owner and retain proof of dispatch to protect against future annulment claims. Failure to do so renders the decisions voidable.

3

Verifying Legality of a Recent Co-ownership Restructuring

Marc is considering purchasing a flat in Marseille in a co-ownership where, three months ago, the AGM voted to withdraw one residential block and turn it into independent lots. The seller assures him the process was compliant, but Marc wants certainty before committing €350,000.

Application pratique:

Under the 28 June 1995 Cassation decision, such a restructuring requires prior notification of draft resolutions to all co-owners. Marc should request the notice of meeting and the accompanying documents (draft resolutions, new service charge apportionments) from the seller or managing agent. If there is no proof of timely delivery, the decisions may be annullable, exposing Marc to future disputes or unexpected costs. He should insert a suspensive clause in the sale contract making the purchase conditional on receiving evidence of proper procedure, and consult a solicitor before signing.

Maître Cécile Zakine

À propos de l'auteur

Maître Cécile Zakine — Avocate au Barreau des Alpes-Maritimes, Docteur en Droit. Chaque article de ce magazine est rédigé à partir de l'analyse d'une décision de jurisprudence réelle, commentée et mise en perspective par les équipes de Maître Zakine.

Prendre rendez-vous →

Avertissement: Les analyses présentées sur ce site sont fournies à titre informatif uniquement et ne constituent pas des conseils juridiques personnalisés. Pour une consultation adaptée à votre situation, contactez un avocat.

★★★★★4.9/5 — Avis Google

Maître Zakine, Doctor of Law

Phone and video consultations available — Fast appointments

Book an appointment
First consultation 30 minutes — €45

🔒 Confidentiel • Sans engagement • Réponse rapide