Aller au contenu principal
Public procurement in New Caledonia: favouritism and the Court of Cassation
Droit Immobilier

Public procurement in New Caledonia: favouritism and the Court of Cassation

📅 Decision of 20 March 2019⚖️ Cour de cassation📖 8 min read

On 20 March 2019, the criminal chamber of the Court of Cassation (France's highest court) quashed a decision of a court of appeal that had acquitted defendants prosecuted for infringing freedom of access and equal treatment of candidates in public procurement in New Caledonia. The Court held that contracts awarded by New Caledonian contracting authorities are indeed subject to Deliberation no. 136/CP of 1 March 1967, which implements those principles. The offence could therefore be prosecuted.

Reference decision: Cass. crim. • No. 17-81.975 • 20 March 2019

On rue de Cambon in Paris, the criminal chamber of the Court of Cassation (the division of France's highest court that hears criminal cases) handed down a judgment on 20 March 2019 that had travelled a long way: from New Caledonia. At the outset was a criminal case involving handling of the proceeds of unlawful taking of interest, a company run by named individuals, and a project to build an office building. But the central issue was a question of principle: do public procurement rules really apply in that territory, to the point of founding criminal prosecutions?

This question matters well beyond lawyers. Whether you are a developer, a builder, the owner of land coveted by a public authority, or simply a business answering a call for tenders, do you know whether the public purchaser that excludes you, or favours a competitor, is breaking a rule enforced by the criminal law? And is a text that sets out broad principles enough to convict someone?

The Court of Cassation answers yes: contracts awarded by New Caledonian contracting authorities are regulated, and it sets aside the acquittal handed down by the court of appeal. Let us look at why, and what it means.

The facts: a story that happens every day

The published elements of this decision are partial, and I confine myself strictly to what they allow me to state. The case is a complex criminal matter, which gave rise to prosecutions for several offences. Among them was handling of the proceeds of unlawful taking of interest (holding or benefiting from an advantage derived from an offence committed by a public official who placed themselves in a conflict of interest), for which certain defendants (the persons prosecuted before the criminal court) had been convicted.

The file also includes a company managed by two individuals, whose purpose was the construction of an office building. That company was intended to be dissolved once the building was completed. This detail matters when assessing whether it was a genuine company, but it does not alter the question put to the Court of Cassation here.

Another strand of the prosecution concerned infringement of freedom of access and equal treatment of candidates in public procurement. This is the offence commonly known as "favouritism": giving an advantage to one candidate, or excluding the others, when a public contract is awarded. On this point, the court of appeal ordered an acquittal (a decision declaring the defendants not guilty). It held that there was no statutory element of the offence capable of founding a prosecution. In other words, no specific text defined the offence in that territory.

An appeal on points of law (an appeal asking the Court of Cassation to verify that the law was correctly applied, without re-examining the facts) was lodged against that acquittal. The judgment discussed here is its outcome.

The court's reasoning, broken down

Everything starts from a fundamental principle of criminal law: the legality of offences. No one may be punished for conduct that the law has not defined precisely in advance. The court of appeal relied on it. In its view, Article 22, 17° of Organic Law no. 99-209 of 19 March 1999 on New Caledonia (the organic law setting out the territory's powers) does set out principles, but that provision does not define any offence. As for Deliberation no. 136/CP of 1 March 1967 regulating public procurement, none of its provisions expressly mentioned freedom of access and equal treatment of candidates. Result: no text, therefore no offence.

The Court of Cassation disagrees. It puts forward two ideas.

First idea: contracts entered into by the contracting authorities (the public bodies that place orders, such as a local authority or a public establishment) of New Caledonia are subject to the rules of the 1967 deliberation. It is not an ancillary text but the foundation that applies in that territory.

Second idea: that deliberation implements the broad principles of public procurement, namely freedom of access, equal treatment of candidates, transparency of procedures, efficiency of public procurement and the proper use of public funds. Those principles are restated in Article 22, 17° of the Law of 19 March 1999 and apply in New Caledonia. The Court therefore refuses to sever the link between the statute and the deliberation. The fact that the deliberation does not reproduce word for word the phrases "freedom of access" and "equal treatment of candidates" does not prevent it from translating them into concrete rules.

The quashing therefore rests on an error of law: the court of appeal based its acquittal on the absence of a statutory element, whereas the framework did exist. The Court does not say that the defendants are guilty. It says that this acquittal, as reasoned, cannot stand. The case must be re-tried on this point.

Should this be seen as a reversal of precedent? No. It is rather a confirmation: public procurement law applies fully overseas, and the criminal court cannot disregard it because a local text is drafted differently from its mainland equivalent.

What this changes for you: in practical terms

If you are a business bidding for a public contract, you may invoke equal treatment even where the applicable regulation does not use those words. If you find that a competitor received information that you did not, or that the specifications were tailor-made, you should keep every document received and the dates of submission. The offence can be prosecuted, which opens the way to a complaint, possibly with the filing of a civil party claim (applying for compensation within the criminal proceedings).

If you are a developer or builder involved in a construction project with a public body, you should check that the award procedure was regular. A contract awarded irregularly is exposed to risk: annulment, litigation, and criminal liability for the decision-makers and their partners. Take an illustrative figure: a €2 million project awarded without competitive tendering may be challenged, and the cost of halting a site quickly exceeds that of a well-run procedure. A firm based in Paris that assists overseas operators also notes that these checks are rarely carried out beforehand.

If you are a public decision-maker or elected official, the message is clear: the argument that "my local text does not provide for this principle" will not protect you. The offence of favouritism, provided for by Article 432-14 of the French Criminal Code, was then punishable by two years' imprisonment and a fine of €200,000.

If you are an owner or shareholder of a construction company, be aware that handling the proceeds of unlawful taking of interest may reach you if you benefit, even indirectly, from an advantage obtained in such conditions. If you are in that situation, you should have the contract award chain reviewed before continuing with the transaction. The limitation period for misdemeanours (délits) is in principle six years, running, depending on the case, from the discovery or the cessation of the acts.

Five tips to avoid this type of dispute

  • Ask for the applicable regulation before bidding. In a territory with its own rules, identify the exact text (here, the 1967 deliberation) and read the provisions on advertising and competitive tendering.
  • Keep a record of every exchange with the public purchaser. Questions, answers, meetings: everything must be capable of being produced, and any information given to one candidate must be given to all.
  • Have the legal structure of a property transaction reviewed. A company created to build a building and then dissolved on delivery must have a genuine economic justification and operate transparently.
  • Declare any conflict of interest. If a family, financial or personal link exists with a decision-maker, report it in writing and remove the person concerned from the decision.
  • Challenge quickly, but through the right channel. If excluded from a contract, you may bring proceedings before the administrative court (as to the procedure) and consider the criminal route. Do not let the time limits pass: seek advice as soon as you are notified of the rejection of your bid.

This judgment forms part of a settled line of authority. The criminal chamber has long held that favouritism penalises breach of the rules that guarantee freedom of access and equal treatment, whether they are laid down by statute, by decree or by an equivalent local text. The principle of legality requires the court to construe criminal law strictly (Article 111-4 of the Criminal Code), but not to deprive it of effect where the text to which it refers does exist.

The distinctive feature of the judgment of 20 March 2019 is its setting: New Caledonia, where competence over public procurement lies with the local authorities. The Court reminds us that this normative autonomy does not create a rule-free zone. I invite you to consult the published decisions of the criminal chamber on Article 432-14 of the Criminal Code: they show that the courts first examine whether a competitive tendering rule exists, and then the conduct of the defendant.

Looking ahead, one can expect the lower courts, notably on remand, to examine more closely the content of the deliberation and the procedural documents of the contract concerned. New Caledonian decision-makers, like their contracting counterparties, will no longer be able to rely on the argument of a gap in the text.

Key takeaways

Before this decision / After

  • Before: a court of appeal could acquit on the ground that no local text expressly mentioned freedom of access and equal treatment of candidates. After: the Court of Cassation affirms that Deliberation no. 136/CP of 1 March 1967 implements those principles and binds contracting authorities.
  • Before: Article 22, 17° of the Law of 19 March 1999 was seen as a mere statement of principles. After: it is recognised as restating principles applicable in the territory, which the deliberation puts into concrete form.
  • Before: the benefit of the doubt could favour defendants on the ground of legality. After: an acquittal based on that ground alone is quashed and the case must be re-tried.
  • Before: excluded businesses hesitated to take action. After: they know that the offence can be prosecuted.
  • What does not change: guilt has not been decided. The Court merely set aside the reasoning.

Are you in a similar situation? A first 30-minute consultation with Maître Zakine (€45) can save you months of proceedings, and often much more. Book an appointment →

📌 Does this apply to your situation? Maître Cécile Zakine, French real estate lawyer, practises throughout France.
→ Prendre rendez-vous pour une consultation  |  → Browse all our legal articles

Legal information

  • Number: 17-81.975
  • Court: Cour de cassation
  • Decision of: 20 March 2019

Keywords

marchés publicsNouvelle-Calédoniefavoritismeégalité des candidatscassation

Practical use cases

1

Building company excluded from a call for tenders

A construction company learns that the contract for an office building has been awarded to a competitor following a procedure that it considers opaque. The contract falls within the remit of a New Caledonian contracting authority.

Practical application:

Since this judgment, the company cannot be met with the argument that there is no express text on equal treatment of candidates. It should gather the tender documents, compare the conditions given to each bidder and have the applicable deliberation analysed. Depending on that analysis, proceedings before the administrative court and a criminal strand may be combined.

2

Developer involved in a special-purpose construction company

A developer sets up with a partner a company intended to build an office building and then to be dissolved on completion. The land or the contract comes from a public body.

Practical application:

The developer should document the regularity of the award and the absence of any conflict of interest on the part of their public counterparts. Failing that, they are exposed to prosecution for handling the proceeds of unlawful taking of interest. A legal review before signing, for example with a Paris-based adviser, limits this risk.

3

Local elected official facing a contested contract

A public decision-maker is accused of having favoured a candidate in awarding a contract, and believes that their local regulation does not expressly provide for equal treatment of candidates.

Practical application:

That argument is weak after the judgment of 20 March 2019, since the principles are restated in Article 22, 17° of the Law of 19 March 1999 and implemented by the 1967 deliberation. They should gather the evidence of competitive tendering and obtain assistance from the investigation stage, without waiting for the trial.

Maître Cécile Zakine

About the author

Maître Cécile Zakine — Lawyer at the Alpes-Maritimes Bar, Doctor of Law. Every article in this magazine is based on the analysis of a real court decision, commented and put into perspective by Maître Zakine’s team.

Book an appointment →

Disclaimer: The analysis presented on this site is for informational purposes only and does not constitute personalised legal advice. For advice tailored to your situation, contact a qualified lawyer.

★★★★★4.9/5 — Google Reviews

Does this affect you?

Consult Maître Zakine — lawyer, Doctor of Law. Fast, clear answer.

Book a consultation →

🔒 Confidential · No obligation

📬 Get legal updates

One legal analysis per week, straight to your inbox. Free, no spam.

🔒 1-click unsubscribe · GDPR compliant

★★★★★4.9/5 — Avis Google

Maître Zakine, Doctor of Law

Phone and video consultations available — Fast appointments

Book an appointment
First consultation 30 minutes — €45

🔒 Confidentiel • Sans engagement • Réponse rapide