It cannot be held against the judges

Application pratique:

The court applied Cass. cc 74-12.631, confirming that a window on the boundary must meet the minimum height for views (usually 1.9m for straight views). Offering to fit fixed glass panes does not cure the breach if the opening itself is too low. The landlord should remove or raise the window to the legal height (at least 1.9m for straight views) before any further work, and consult a French property lawyer to avoid daily fines.

Application pratique:

This case shows courts strictly enforce height rules even after purchase; the buyer could face a removal order like in Cass. cc 74-12.631. Before completing the sale, the buyer should have the window height measured and, if non-compliant, negotiate a price reduction or require the seller to regularise. If already bound, seek legal advice immediately, as a neighbour can demand removal regardless of the buyer's good faith.

Application pratique:

The ruling in Cass. cc 74-12.631 means the co-owner cannot simply install fixed glass panes to avoid a straight view; the opening must comply with Article 677 height rules (1.9m minimum for a straight view). The co-owner should either block up the window or raise it to the legal height, and should do so promptly to avoid a court order for removal plus damages. Consulting a French avocat specialising in copropriété is advisable before any works.