Reference Decision: cc • No. 21-19.936 • 2023-07-21
You have just bought a villa in Mandelieu-la-Napoule with a sea view, and six months later you discover significant cracks in the load-bearing walls. The seller assured you everything was in order. Panic stations: how long do you have to sue him? And if you are the seller, how long can you be pursued? This question is asked by hundreds of property owners each year on the Côte d'Azur, where real estate is king and defects are sometimes well hidden.
The answer comes from the French Supreme Court in a judgment of 21 July 2023 (No. 21-19.936). It restates the rules: an action for latent defects must be brought within two years of discovering the defect, but there is a 20-year longstop from the initial sale. A subtle balance between protecting the buyer and providing legal certainty for the seller.
Whether you are a buyer, seller or property professional in Mougins or elsewhere, this judgment clarifies your rights and obligations. Let us break it down simply.
The Facts: A Story That Happens Every Day
Mr X, owner of a flat in Mandelieu, sells it to Mr Y in 2010. A few years later, Mr Y discovers recurring water ingress and hidden defects. He sues Mr X in 2018. Mr X then seeks an indemnity from his own seller, Mr Z, from whom he had bought the property in 2005. Problem: between the initial sale (2005) and the indemnity claim (2018), more than 13 years have passed. The original seller argues that the claim is time-barred. The lower courts ruled in favour of Mr Y, ordering Mr X to compensate him, but rejected Mr X's claim against Mr Z, holding that the 20-year longstop had expired? No, it is not that simple. The Court of Appeal had applied a 10-year limitation period, but the Supreme Court quashes the decision: it states that the 20-year longstop applies and runs from the sale by the party against whom the indemnity is sought, here the 2005 sale. The indemnity claim was made in 2018, i.e. within 20 years. Therefore, Mr X's recourse action against Mr Z was not time-barred. The case is remitted.
The Court's Reasoning — Explained
The Supreme Court relies on two provisions: Article 1648, paragraph 1, of the Civil Code, which sets the time limit for a latent defect claim at two years from discovery, and Article 2232 of the same Code, which establishes a 20-year longstop from the date the right arises, regardless of the applicable limitation period. In latent defect cases, the right arises on the date of the sale by the party against whom the claim is made. For the buyer's main claim against his seller, the longstop therefore runs from the sale between them. For a recourse claim (the seller seeking an indemnity from his own seller), the longstop runs from the sale between those two parties.
The Court clarifies that this longstop applies to commercial or mixed sales concluded before the entry into force of the Law of 17 June 2008 (which extended the limitation period from 10 to 20 years), if the previous 10-year period had not expired at that date. For civil sales, it applies from the entry into force of the Law, provided that the total duration does not exceed that provided for by the previous law. In other words, the Court harmonises the regimes by imposing a 20-year cap while respecting acquired rights.
In short, a seller can no longer be pursued beyond 20 years after the sale, even if the defect is discovered later. This provides security for sellers, but also a reminder for buyers: do not delay in taking action!
What This Means for You — Practically
For the buyer: if you discover a latent defect, you have two years to bring legal proceedings from that discovery. But beware: if you bought more than 20 years ago, you are too late, even if the defect has just been discovered. Example: you buy a house in Mougins in 2005, and in 2024 you discover hidden termites. You can act until 2026 (2 years after discovery), but not beyond 2025 (20 years after the sale). So in reality, you only have until 2025. You must be reactive.
For the seller: you are protected beyond 20 years. But if you are sued by your own buyer, you can in turn sue your own seller, provided that the claim is made within 20 years of your purchase. In the case, the intermediate seller (Mr X) could sue his seller (Mr Z) because the claim was made within 13 years.
For the property professional: these time limits are mandatory. Make sure you inform your clients of the risks and deadlines. A warranty clause in the sale deed can be useful, but it does not extend the longstop.
Few people know that the two-year period can be interrupted by an interim application or a acknowledgment of debt. But the 20-year longstop is absolute: no interruption extends it.
Four Tips to Avoid This Type of Dispute
- Carry out pre-sale surveys: a full technical survey (termites, asbestos, lead, electricity, gas) can reveal potential defects. In Mandelieu, termites are common; in Mougins, humidity can cause hidden mould. Investing a few hundred euros can save you thousands in litigation.
- Keep all documents relating to the sale and works: sale deed, surveys, invoices for works, correspondence. In case of dispute, you can prove the date of sale and the condition of the property.
- Act quickly once a problem is discovered: do not delay consulting a solicitor. The two years run from discovery, but if you wait, you risk exceeding the longstop. As soon as you notice a defect, have it recorded by an expert (bailiff, court expert) and send a recorded delivery letter to the seller.
- When selling, include a time-limited latent defects warranty clause: you can provide that your warranty applies only for a specified period (e.g. 5 years), but beware, this clause cannot reduce the legal two-year period from discovery. It can only limit your contractual liability.
Further Analysis: Related Case Law and Developments
The Supreme Court had already addressed this issue in a judgment of 13 July 2022 (No. 21-17.057), where it held that the 20-year longstop applies to latent defect claims, even for sales prior to the 2008 Law. The 2023 judgment confirms this position and extends it to recourse actions. The trend is therefore towards securing transactions: sellers can no longer be pursued indefinitely, which is consistent with the concept of limitation of actions in French law. For the future, we can expect judges to be increasingly strict about compliance with these deadlines, especially in latent defect cases where proof of the date of discovery is often disputed.
In Practice: What You Need to Do
FAQ
- Q: I discovered a latent defect 3 years ago, can I still act? A: No, the 2-year period has expired. You are time-barred, unless you can prove that you only recently discovered the defect (e.g., it was hidden and only now appeared).
- Q: The seller concealed a defect, but the sale was 25 years ago. Can I sue? A: No, the 20-year longstop has expired. You can no longer bring a latent defect claim.
- Q: I am a tenant, can I sue the landlord for a latent defect? A: Yes, but the time limits are the same: 2 years from discovery, and 20 years from the sale between the landlord and his seller. In practice, the tenant can sue the landlord, who can then seek recourse against the seller.
- Q: What if the defect is discovered after 19 years? A: Act immediately! You have one year to sue. Consult a solicitor without delay.
Besoin d'un conseil personnalisé ? Contactez Maître Zakine — première consultation 30 min à 45€.
Are you in a similar situation? A 30-minute initial consultation with Maître Zakine (€45) can save you months of proceedings — and often much more. Book an appointment →
