Reference decision: cc • No. 85-41.081 • 1987-11-12 • View decision →
You are an executive in the metallurgy industry, in Valbonne or Cagnes-sur-Mer. You resign, and your employer reminds you that you are bound by a non-competition clause. You wonder: will I receive the compensation payment? And if my employer waives the clause, can they do so after the start of my notice period?
This question was put to the Court of Cassation by an employee in 1987. And the answer is of direct interest to any employer or employee subject to a non-competition clause, particularly in the metallurgy, engineering and consulting sectors.
The decision of 12 November 1987 (No. 85-41.081) clarifies the starting point of the 8-day period within which the employer may release the employee from the non-competition obligation. And it distinguishes according to whether the employee has served his notice period or not. Explanations.
The facts: a story that happens every day
Mr X, an engineer in a metallurgy company, resigns on 19 June 1979. He announces that he is leaving his position with immediate effect, without serving any notice period (the period of work following resignation, usually 1 to 3 months). He nevertheless starts working during the notice period, but his employer, by letter of 27 June, releases him from his non-competition clause. The employer considers that the effective termination occurred on 19 June, and that his letter of 27 June is within the 8-day period.
The employee, however, argues that the employer should have released him within 8 days of the notification of resignation, i.e., before 27 June. He claims payment of the non-competition compensation (the sum due by the employer in return for the prohibition on working for a competitor).
The Court of Appeal rules in favour of the employer. The employee appeals to the Court of Cassation. The Court of Cassation dismisses his appeal: it confirms that the 8-day period runs from the effective termination of the contract, not from the notification of resignation. In this case, since the employee did not serve any notice period, the effective termination occurred on 19 June, and the employer complied with the time limit by writing on 27 June.
The reasoning of the court — explained
The Court of Cassation relies on Article 26 of the collective agreement for engineers and executives in the metallurgy industry (the text governing labour relations in this sector). This article provides that the employer may discharge his obligation to pay the non-competition compensation by releasing the employee from this clause, provided that he does so in writing within the 8 days following the notification of notice, or, if the employee does not serve his notice period, within the 8 days following the effective termination of the contract.
The key word is "effective termination". The Court distinguishes two situations: if the employee serves his notice period, the time limit runs from the notification of notice (the date on which the employer knows that the employee is leaving); if the employee does not serve his notice period (resignation without notice, or dispensation from notice), the time limit runs from the effective termination, i.e., the last day worked.
In this case, the employee resigned without notice: the effective termination occurred on 19 June. The employer wrote on 27 June, i.e., within 8 days. The Court clarifies that the employee cannot rely on a partial performance of the notice period to start the time limit earlier. What few people know: as long as the notice period is not fully served, the employer retains the right to waive the clause within 8 days of the termination.
However, be careful: if the employee had served a notice period, the employer would have had to act within 8 days of the notification of that notice. In other words, the starting point varies depending on whether the employee works during his notice period.
What this means for you — practically
For the employer: you should check the date of effective termination of the contract. If the employee resigns without notice, you have 8 days from his actual departure to release him from the non-competition clause. If you exceed this time limit, you will be obliged to pay the compensation (often 30 to 50% of annual salary). Concrete example: an executive in Cagnes-sur-Mer resigns on 1 February 2025 without notice. You must notify your waiver by 9 February 2025 at the latest (since 1 February is the day of termination, the period expires 8 days later).
For the employee: if your employer releases you from the non-competition clause after the start of your notice period, check the date of your resignation. If you have not served any notice period, the employer can still do so within 8 days of your actual departure. Conversely, if you serve your notice period, the employer must act within 8 days of your notification of resignation. If not, you can claim the compensation.
For the real estate professional: a non-competition clause may also exist in agency or lease-management contracts. The same logic applies: the waiver period runs from the effective termination of the contract. If you are a purchaser of a business with a non-competition clause, be attentive to dates.
Four tips to avoid this type of dispute
- Tip 1: For the employer, notify the waiver in writing within 8 days of the effective termination. Do not rely on the notification of resignation if the employee does not serve his notice period. Use registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt.
- Tip 2: For the employee, keep proof of the date of your resignation and the employer's notification. If your employer releases you after the deadline, you can claim the compensation.
- Tip 3: In case of dispensation from notice, clearly define the date of effective termination. undefined, I have come across cases where the employer and employee did not agree on the contract end date. A written document is essential.
- Tip 4: Check your collective agreement. Article 26 of the metallurgy agreement is an example, but other agreements may provide for different time limits (10 days, 15 days). Do not assume the 8-day period is universal.
Besoin d'un conseil personnalisé ? Contactez Maître Zakine — première consultation 30 min à 45€.
Further reading: related case law and developments
The 1987 decision is part of a series of rulings clarifying the modalities of waiver of the non-competition clause. For example, the Court of Cassation has held (Soc., 10 March 1998, No. 95-44.732) that the waiver must be express and unequivocal. Mere silence by the employer is not sufficient to discharge his obligation to pay the compensation.
More recently, the Court has reiterated that the 8-day period is a limitation period (a period after which a right is lost): if the employer fails to comply with this period, he is time-barred (can no longer waive) and must pay the compensation. The trend of the courts is protective towards the employee: they require the employer to act quickly and unambiguously.
Looking ahead, it can be expected that the courts will continue to clarify the concept of "effective termination", particularly in cases of partially performed notice or dispensation from notice.
In practice: what to do
FAQ:
1. My employer released me from the clause 10 days after my resignation without notice. Can I claim the compensation?
Yes, if the effective termination occurred on the day of your resignation, the 8-day period was exceeded. You can demand payment of the non-competition compensation.
2. I am an employer. Can I waive the clause before the employee's resignation?
Yes, you can waive it at any time, but it is preferable to do so after the termination to avoid any dispute over the starting point of the time limit.
3. What if the employee does not comply with the non-competition clause?
You may claim damages (pecuniary compensation) and seek to stop the breach. But if you did not release him within the time limits, you owe the compensation.
4. Is the non-competition clause always valid?
It must be limited in time (usually 6 months to 2 years) and in space (reasonable geographical area). Otherwise, it may be annulled by a judge.
5. In case of redundancy, does the same time limit apply?
Yes, the principle is the same: the employer has 8 days from the effective termination of the contract to release the employee. Note: the effective termination is the date of notification of redundancy, except where the employee is dispensed from serving notice.
Are you in a similar situation? A 30-minute initial consultation with Maître Zakine (€45) can save you months of proceedings — and often much more. Book an appointment →
