Expulsion: bailiff must return personal effects within one month

Imagine: you are a tenant in Toulouse, you receive an order to vacate the premises. A few weeks later, the bailiff arrives, your belongings are put on the pavement, and you wonder: 'Will I ever see my sofa, my family photos, my books again?' I have seen this fear in the eyes of many clients in Pamiers and Toulouse. Fortunately, the Court of Cassation has ruled: the evicted person has the right to recover their personal effects within one month of the eviction, and the bailiff is obliged to return them. But what exactly does this change? Let's break it down.

The facts: a story that happens every day

Mr X, a landlord in Pamiers, had obtained the eviction of his tenant, Mr Y, for rent arrears. The interim order of 19 November 2009 ordered the eviction. On 15 March 2010, the bailiff carried out the eviction. Immediately afterwards, he also carried out a seizure-sale of some of Mr Y's property to recover the rent owed. But Mr Y had not given up: he demanded the return of his personal belongings that had not been seized – including furniture, clothes, documents. The bailiff refused, arguing that the eviction was over and the property was now the landlord's responsibility. Mr Y then applied to the enforcement judge for restitution. The first instance court ruled in his favour, but the Court of Appeal overturned this decision, considering that the one-month period had already elapsed. The case went up to the Court of Cassation. It finally ruled in favour of Mr Y: the bailiff remains responsible for returning personal effects for one month, regardless of whether the deadline has passed. However, note: the one-month period runs from the service of the eviction report, not from the eviction itself. What few people know is that the bailiff must keep the goods in a safe place and return them upon simple request. undefined, I have come across cases where evicted tenants in Toulouse had to wait weeks to recover their belongings due to lack of information about their rights.

The reasoning of the court – explained

The Court of Cassation relies on Articles L. 433-1 and R. 433-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures. Article L. 433-1 provides that 'movable objects that are not seized are left at the disposal of the evicted person'. Article R. 433-1 specifies that the bailiff 'informs the evicted person that they have a period of one month to collect their property'. In short, the legislature intended to protect the evicted tenant by giving them a month to move their belongings without pressure. But the question was: what happens if the bailiff does not return the goods? The Court of Appeal considered that the one-month period was a final deadline, after which the bailiff was no longer obliged. The Court of Cassation says no: the right to restitution exists throughout the one-month period, and the bailiff, as the person responsible for executing the eviction measure, must return the goods if the person requests them within that period. In other words, it is not a time-bar, but a period of protection. If the person does not claim their property within the month, the landlord can have it removed at their own expense (Article L. 433-2). But if they do claim it, the bailiff must return it. The judges also recalled that the bailiff incurs liability if they do not return the goods properly (Article 1240 of the Civil Code, which requires compensation for damage caused by their fault). This reasoning confirms previous case law (Civ. 2nd, 13 January 2011, No. 09-72.507) and reinforces it: the bailiff is not a mere executor, but the guarantor of respect for the rights of the evicted person.

What this changes for you – concretely

If you are a tenant threatened with eviction: you have one month from the service of the eviction report to claim your personal belongings from the bailiff. This deadline is imperative: after this month, the landlord can remove your belongings and you will have to pay for storage. Example: in Toulouse, a tenant evicted on 1 March receives the report on 3 March. They have until 3 April to claim their belongings. If they wait until 5 April, it is too late. If you are a landlord: you must ensure that the bailiff informs the tenant of their right to restitution. undefined, I recommend asking for proof of this information. If the tenant does not claim anything within the month, you can have the goods removed at your expense (allow between €200 and €500 for clearance in the Toulouse area). But beware: if you destroy or throw away goods that the tenant had claimed before the month expires, you incur liability. If you are a bailiff: this decision reminds you of your duty to inform and to return. You must keep the goods in a safe place and return them on request. If you fail, you may be ordered to pay damages. In a case I handled in Pamiers, a bailiff had to pay €1,500 for refusing to return clothes and identity papers.

Four tips to avoid this type of dispute

• For the landlord: have the eviction report served by a bailiff and insist that it clearly mentions the one-month period for recovering the goods. Keep a copy of the service.
• For the tenant: as soon as you receive the eviction report, send a registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt to the bailiff claiming your belongings, listing precisely what you want to recover. If necessary, be assisted by a commissaire de justice (formerly huissier).
• For both parties: take photos of the premises before and after the eviction. This can serve as evidence in case of a dispute over the condition of the goods.
• For everyone: consult a lawyer specialising in property law at the first sign of trouble. A quick consultation can avoid much higher legal costs. For example, in Toulouse, early intervention may cost €200, whereas a trial can exceed €3,000.

Besoin d'un conseil personnalisé ? Contactez Maître Zakine — première consultation 30 min à 45€.

Further analysis: related case law and developments

This decision is part of a protective line of case law for the rights of evicted persons. The Court of Cassation had already ruled, in a judgment of 13 January 2011 (No. 09-72.507), that the bailiff must return the goods even if the one-month period has expired, provided that the person claimed them within the period. Here, it clarifies that the right to restitution exists throughout the month, and the bailiff cannot evade it. Another decision, of 19 March 2015 (No. 14-10.983), extended this obligation to seized goods: the bailiff must return them after the sale if the proceeds were insufficient to satisfy the creditor. The trend is clear: the courts want to prevent eviction from turning into spoliation. In the future, we can expect bailiffs' liability to be further strengthened, particularly regarding information and preservation of goods.

Frequently asked questions

1. Can I recover my goods after the one-month period? No, unless you claimed them within the period. After this month, the landlord can dispose of the goods (throw them away, give them away, etc.).
2. What if the bailiff refuses to return my goods? Apply to the enforcement judge by way of interim proceedings. You can also claim damages if the bailiff is at fault (Article 1240 of the Civil Code).
3. Which goods are concerned? All unseized personal belongings: furniture, clothes, documents, valuables. Goods seized in a seizure-sale are treated separately.
4. Can the bailiff charge me for the return? Yes, storage and transport costs may be charged to you, but they must be reasonable. In practice, allow between €50 and €150.
5. Can I require the bailiff to let me into the property to collect my belongings? Yes, the bailiff must allow you access to the property to collect your belongings, under normal conditions (e.g., by appointment).

Are you in a similar situation? A first 30-minute consultation with Maître Zakine (€45) can save you months of proceedings – and often much more. Book an appointment →