Promise of sale void if suspensive condition not fulfilled by the stipulated deadline

Imagine: you own a house in Tournefeuille, near Toulouse. You have signed a preliminary contract of sale with a buyer. The sale is scheduled for 30 June, subject to a suspensive condition of obtaining a loan. 30 June arrives, the buyer has not obtained his loan. Can the sale still take place? The answer is no, according to the Court of Cassation in its judgment of 9 March 2017 (no. 15-26.182). The promise is void. But what does that actually change? Let's break it down.

The facts: an everyday story

Mrs Y. owns a flat in Pamiers, Ariège. On 20 March 2010, she signs a synallagmatic promise of sale (i.e., a preliminary contract) with Mr X., the buyer. The price is €150,000. The sale must be concluded by notarial deed (before a notary) no later than 30 June 2010. The preliminary contract includes a suspensive condition of obtaining a loan: Mr X. must obtain a loan of €120,000 before 30 June. On 30 June, Mr X. has still not obtained his loan. He has not waived the condition (i.e., he has not agreed to buy without a loan). Mrs Y. considers the sale perfected and sues Mr X. for payment of the price and damages. The Tribunal de Grande Instance of Foix rules in her favour in 2013: the sale is perfected. Mr X. appeals. The Court of Appeal of Toulouse, in 2015, reverses the judgment: it declares the preliminary contract void and dismisses Mrs Y.'s claims. Mrs Y. appeals to the Court of Cassation. The Court of Cassation dismisses her appeal on 9 March 2017. It confirms that the promise is void because the suspensive condition was not fulfilled by the date set for the conclusion of the sale.

The court's reasoning — explained

The Court of Cassation relies on Article 1176 of the Civil Code (in its version applicable before the 2016 reform of contract law). This article provides that if an obligation is contracted under a suspensive condition, it is void if the condition is not fulfilled within the agreed time. In other words, when a preliminary contract of sale sets a deadline for the fulfilment of the suspensive condition, and by the date fixed for the signature of the notarial deed the condition has not been fulfilled, the promise is void by operation of law (automatically), without the need to seek rescission (annulment) of the contract. However, this assumes that the buyer has not waived the condition. In this case, Mr X. had not waived it. The Court also recalls that the seller cannot demand specific performance of the sale (force the buyer to buy) nor obtain damages under Article 1240 of the Civil Code (which requires compensation for damage caused by fault), because the buyer has not committed any fault in failing to fulfil a condition over which he has no control (obtaining a loan). What few people know: the deadline set in the preliminary contract is strict. Even if the condition is not fulfilled the day after the deadline, the contract is void. The judges apply a strict interpretation.

What this means for you — practically

For a seller: if your buyer does not obtain his loan within the stipulated time, you cannot force him to buy. You must put the property back on the market. Concrete example: in Pamiers, a property worth €150,000. If the condition is not lifted by 30 June, you lose time. However, you can negotiate an extension of the time limit by way of an addendum (a written document signed by both parties). For a buyer: if your loan is not obtained in time, you are released from all obligations. You get your deposit back (unless there is an abusive clause to the contrary). But beware: if you waive the suspensive condition, you are obliged to buy even without a loan. undefined, I have come across cases where buyers have unwisely waived the condition and found themselves in debt. For an estate agent or notary: be vigilant about dates. Just one day's delay and the contract is void. It is prudent to include an automatic extension clause or an amicable termination clause.

Four tips to avoid this type of dispute

• Set a realistic deadline for the suspensive condition: allow at least 45 to 60 days for obtaining a loan. A deadline that is too short increases the risk of voidness.
• Include an automatic extension clause: in the preliminary contract, state that if the condition is not fulfilled by the stipulated date, the deadline is automatically extended by 15 days, unless the seller objects.
• Do not waive the suspensive condition without advice: a buyer should never waive the condition without being certain of obtaining financing elsewhere (e.g., a family loan).
• Monitor the dates closely: if you are a seller, ask the buyer for regular updates on the progress of his loan. If you are a buyer, inform the seller as soon as the loan is refused to avoid any misunderstanding.

Further reading: related case law and developments

The Court of Cassation has already ruled in the same vein, for example in a judgment of 10 September 2014 (no. 13-20.448): the promise is void if the condition is not fulfilled on the fixed day, even if the buyer submitted a loan application before the deadline expired. However, a more recent decision of 13 January 2021 (no. 19-23.107) qualifies this: if the condition is fulfilled after the deadline but before the seller has notified the voidness, the sale may be upheld if the buyer proves that the delay is attributable to the bank. The current trend is therefore to protect the bona fide buyer, but the principle remains automatic voidness. For the future, it is advisable to include clear clauses to avoid disputes.

In practice: what to do

Checklist for the buyer:
1. Before signing the preliminary contract, check the deadline for the suspensive condition (minimum 45 days).
2. Submit your loan application immediately after signing.
3. If the loan is not obtained in time, inform the seller in writing (by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt) and request the return of the deposit.
4. If you still want to buy, negotiate an extension of the deadline by addendum.
5. In case of dispute, consult a lawyer specialising in property law.

Are you in a similar situation? A 30-minute initial consultation with Maître Zakine (€45) can save you months of litigation — and often much more. Book an appointment →